Sunday, April 20, 2008

10:01 pm

SIGs, second rate CCAs?

This article is for publishing on NYConneXions for both online and the print edition. But I decided to post it here ahead of time for the benefit of my readers. The roots of this article can be traced back to here. This was primarily written by Stanley and edited by me so I cannot claim all the credit.

The research of this article also reached the upper levels. To ensure a balanced view from the school authorities, elements from an email reply (in my previous post)from Mr William Yeo (Coordinator of NYJC SIGs) of my query is integrated into this article. Happy reading!


Ex-minister of Education, Mr. Tharman Shanmugaratnam, gave his encouragement for students to set up self-managed activities within their schools in his 2004 speech.

Four years on, many such student-managed organisations have been initiated in various educational institutions around Singapore. Nanyang Junior College too has seen numerous Student-Interest Groups (SIGs) being set up, these includes the Floorball team, J-fire club as well as the new Joke Club.

However, there are concerns associated with these SIGs, the most prominent misconception is that they are second-rate activities set up by students and not worth joining as such as they are not “official” and thus less prestigious to. This due to the fact they are mainly autonomous and are largely managed by their student members. However, this view has no truth to it; these SIGs are in fact beneficial to their members as they are given an opportunity to independently manage their organizations independently, especially in the areas of finance and organisation of activities matters.

A greater level of commitment, discipline, enthusiasm and certainly, leadership is required to ensure the sustainability of these SIGs hence, the success of any SIG will speak immensely well of the students leading and managing it. Most importantly, these SIGs are indeed recognized by the school authorities and they are even given funding on a case-by-case basis as well as opportunities to showcase their activities to others.

However, two further problems have been plaguing these SIGs including the tedious application process of setting up their activities as well as getting funding for their organizations.

The first problem was the cited by both the presidents of Floorball and J-fire as the initial bugbear. They had to convince the school authorities that their SIGs were able to benefit its members through its activities and allowing them to pick up holistic values such as, Integrity, Resilience, Compassion, Resourcefulness and Teamwork. This had to be reflected through the paperwork. Eddy (Floorball Team Captain) had to explain in detail the rules of the game as well as the safety measures. Pauline (J-fire’s president) had to present extensive proposals on cosplay (Japanese costume dress-up) and anime/manga-related activities such as drawing competitions.

Funding is a more acute problem for SIGs as they do not have a steady flow allocated by the school. For instance each Floorball team member had to pay approximately 35 to 200 dollars for a personal Floorball Stick. On top of that, they had to fork out monthly coach fees from their own pocket.. This is certainly not a small sum for any school-going teenager. At the moment, both organizations are hoping to convert into official CCAs and they hope that increased steadier funding would be provided for their activities as they gain recognition in the school.

Despite the challenges, these SIGs have also won many accolades and have brought recognition to themselves; the most prominent of these would be the school’s Floorball team which is currently competing at the A’ division national level. The J-fire club has also been active in the Singapore Cosplay scene and has been working on a professional basis with the Singapore Cosplay organization and similar clubs at other junior colleges. Piano Ensemble too has entertained us in many college events such as Synergy and the College Day. They have also contributed to the community by performing at the Singapore General Hospital and Cancer Foundation.

Hopefully this article is able to shed greater light on these SIGs within the school. Like CCAs, SIGs have activities that are beyond academic pursuits while still being able to enhance the overall vibrancy of the school’s culture. They deserve our encouragement to further their works within and outside Nanyang JC. Certainly, without the initiative of the student members of these SIGs, NYJCians would be missing out on many alternative activities that CCAs might not be able to offer. For that, these SIGs deserve our kudos and support.

To set up SIGs, one can approach HOD for PE/CCA, Mrs. Koh Siew Leng or SIG Co-ordinator, Mr. William Yeo for advice and to obtain the application forms. Get 3 commited members and submit a proposal.

By: Stanley and Yeo Kheng Meng


0 Comment(s)

Post a Comment

Posted by yeokm1 aka the insigificant observer

























 Subscribe in a reader

Subscribe to posts via Email

Comments feed

Minimum Page Requirements
Best viewed at 1024x768 resolution
16 colours (16-bit recommended)
Optimised for Mozilla Firefox 3.0
A text browser will also do
Tahoma, Georgia & Verdana fonts
IE STRONGLY not recommended
No operating system limitation

Recent posts

Reply from school authorities
MIDC 2008 Day 2
General 11: A breather...
MIDC 2008 Day 1
Debates + PW and block test results
The end of the "someone" situation
Tagged + Tagboard replies
All results + Meet-the-parents
The end I promise


May 2007 ::: June 2007 ::: July 2007 ::: August 2007 ::: September 2007 ::: October 2007 ::: November 2007 ::: December 2007 ::: January 2008 ::: February 2008 ::: March 2008 ::: April 2008 ::: May 2008 ::: June 2008 ::: July 2008 ::: August 2008 ::: September 2008 ::: October 2008 ::: November 2008 ::: December 2008 ::: January 2009 ::: February 2009 ::: March 2009 ::: April 2009 ::: May 2009 ::: June 2009 ::: July 2009 ::: August 2009 ::: September 2009 ::: October 2009 ::: November 2009 ::: December 2009 ::: January 2010 ::: February 2010 ::: March 2010 ::: April 2010 ::: June 2010 ::: August 2010 ::: September 2010 ::: October 2010 ::: November 2010 ::: December 2010 ::: January 2011 ::: April 2011 ::: May 2011 ::: July 2011 ::: October 2011 ::: December 2011 ::: February 2013 :::


0713 ::: Blog Admin ::: CCA ::: Computers ::: Education ::: General ::: Mathematics ::: Media ::: Milestones::: Science & Tech ::: Singapore ::: Politics :::


0713 Blog
0713 Forum
Chuen Hwee
Guo Hao
Hong Hao
Jia Cheng
Jia Rong
John Tan
Jun Hong
Wei Han
Yan Chao


Benjamin Cheah
Hao Yi
Mr Seah
Peer Tutoring
Ying Yi


AMKSS blog
AMKSS Infotech Club
Han Ling
Hua Zhen
Jason Teo
Jia Min
Jocelyn Tan
Mrs Chung
Shiuan Shiuan
Xin Yi


Benjamin Low
Ming Ching
Phil Shapiro
Pico Ruiz
Zhong Hao
Darren Lee

NYJC/Geek/Misc pages

Official website
Student Leaders

Game for tweaking?
Geek gadgets galore!
News for nerds (or geeks)
PCworld Community Voices

4/2 forums (probably defunct)
Diary of a Singaporean Mind
Little Speck
Mr Brown
Mr Wang Says So
The Online Citizen
Sammyboy's Alfresco
Singapore SC for Reform
Singapore Angle
Singapore Patriot
Singapore Window
The Thinker
To Fix a Mocking Peasant
Xenoboy in SG
Visit the PCWorld forums!

My Mascot

I'm Kheng Meng, yeokm1 aka "the insignificant observer"

Came to life on 5 September 1990


3.Blogskin testbed
4.Private blog (ceased posting)

View my Profile

Search posts

My schools

NS STTS MSET F23/09-10 G2
NS 3 Signal Batallion TCC2 UIP
NS Signals 04/08 Infocomm 1 WACTC
NS BMT Orion Coy Platoon 3 Section 2
Nanyang JC 0713, Tribe27, 0720, OG18
Ang Mo Kio Sec 4/2, 3/2, 2/5, 1/5
Rosyth Primary 6-03 , 5-03, 4-01, 3AC, 2AF, 1A6